Skip to Main Content
Research Help
Services for You
About the Library
Digital Design Studio
Cleveland Memory
MYCSU
Search the Library
Michael Schwartz Library
216.687.2478
Michael Schwartz Library
Michael Schwartz Library
Research Guides
Writing Your Journal Article in 12 Weeks Writing Club
Week 9: Giving, Getting, & Using Feedback
Search this Guide
Search
Writing Your Journal Article in 12 Weeks Writing Club
A guide for students participating in the CSU writing club using the text Writing Your Journal Article in 12 Weeks by Wendy Laura Belcher.
Home
Week 1: Designing Your Plan for Writing
Week 2: Starting Your Article
Week 3: Advancing Your Argument
Week 4: Selecting a Journal
Week 5: Reviewing the Related Literature
Week 6: Strengthening Your Structure
Week 7: Presenting Your Evidence
Week 8: Opening & Concluding Your Article
Week 9: Giving, Getting, & Using Feedback
Week 10: Editing Your Sentences
Week 11: Wrapping Up Your Article
Week 12: Sending Your Article!
Week X: Responding to Journal Decisions
Week 9: Giving, Getting, & Using Feedback
Discussion Questions
Weekly Tasks
Notes & Ideas
Who would be willing and able to give you feedback about your article draft?
What specific things would you direct your reviewer to consider or give feedback about?
Revising and Resubmitting Your Article
Panopto video by Mary McDonald
Share your article with someone else for feedback. If appropriate, provide feedback to your reviewer as well.
Make a list of remaining tasks.
Revise your article according to the feedback you received.
Ways to Accept Feedback
Tell your reviewer what feedback you need.
Avoid taking poorly delivered feedback with anger. Focus on the message, not the delivery.
Listen without interrupting.
Recognize that any reaction to your work is an indicator of how future readers may react.
Remember that you are the final authority on your own article.
Relevant Resources
Seven Keys to Effective Feedback
Educational Leadership, Grant Wiggins
Seven Characteristics of Effective Feedback
Oxford University Press
How to Give Constructive Peer Feedback
Elsevier
Short Video on Giving, Receiving, and Using Feedback
By Mary McDonald, CSU Writing Center Director
<<
Previous:
Week 8: Opening & Concluding Your Article
Next:
Week 10: Editing Your Sentences >>